Mindy Maple is a 21 year old college student who has no idea what to do with her life. She is involved with the college paper, and while the sports correspondent is out sick she’s tasked with reporting on the game, which she loathes.

However, she notices Donny and Mick, two stars of the college who seem to have a telepathic understanding. Both men are handsome and at a party afterwards she gets to meet them, and finds the both irresistible.

Making excuses to see them again, Mindy finds herself dating both men at once and she can’t choose between them. Will one of them take her virginity or will they find out her secret, or is there yet a third possibility Mindy hasn’t even considered…?